Back to search

5805 Custer Road

New Plymouth, ID, 83655

PENDING

$475,000Price

4Beds

1665Sq Ft

Unsave

Save

5805 Custer Road, New Plymouth, ID, 83655

5805 Custer Road

New Plymouth, ID, 83655

PENDING

$475,000Price

4Beds

1665Sq Ft

Unsave

Save

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker/Classic Proper

Attribution contact:

broker@coldwellbankerclassicproperties.com

Description

Discover the charm of country living in this cozy spot nestled in rural Payette County. Just a little over two miles from I-84 (Exit 3) and roughly three miles from the New Plymouth Post Office, this place gives you the best of both worlds—peaceful surroundings and easy access to town. Located in the Fruitland School District and surrounded by farmland, you'll enjoy wide-open spaces and hardly any nearby development. When you drive up the paved driveway, you'll find plenty of room for parking and a spacious yard. There's a ton of potential here, whether you want to add a shop, a garage, or anything else you might dream up. The house itself features rustic updates, yet still offers room for you to add your personal flair. Owned by the seller’s family for many years, this property is a rare find. It's a chance to grab a slice of quiet, country bliss in a stunning rural setting. The home is currently rented out, so please give us a heads-up to schedule a tour. Don't miss out on this chance to dive into the best of country living!

Information

Price: $475,000

Days On Market: 93

Year Build: 1913

Square Footage: 1,665 Sq ft

Bedrooms: 4

MLS ID: 98970755

Status: Pending

Nearby Schools

FruitlandElementary School

FruitlandMiddle School

FruitlandHigh School

Details

Address: 5805 Custer Road

County: Payette

City: New Plymouth

Neighborhood: 0 not applicable

Zip: 83655

State: Idaho

Taxes

Property Taxes: $598

Tax Year: 2025

Tax Amount: $598

Location

Listed By

Listing Agent

Jeff Williams

broker@coldwellbankerclassicproperties.com

Coldwell Banker/Classic Proper

Similar Listings

Newly Listed

6031 Backcountry Pl, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98979557

PENDING

$545,899

4 Beds

Listing Office: Hubble Homes, LLC

3813 2456 E, Filer, ID, 83328

MLS# 98979379

PENDING

$545,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Silvercreek Realty Group

Virtual Tour

Newly Listed

11359 Langit St, Star, ID, 83669

MLS# 98979100

ACTIVE

$545,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Amherst Madison

Newly Listed

17749 Hugh Glass Way, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98978053

PENDING

$544,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Newly Listed

3446 Fitz Roy St., Kuna, ID, 83634

MLS# 98983338

ACTIVE

$544,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: New Home Star Idaho

Newly Listed

5611 Garby St. UNIT Lot 17 Block 8, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98973453

PENDING

$544,977

4 Beds

Listing Office: New Home Star Idaho

Virtual Tour

8886 Inspirado St, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98977612

ACTIVE

$544,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Virtual Tour

8942 Inspirado St, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98972906

PENDING

$544,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Newly Listed

1747 Yellowstone Court, Lewiston, ID, 83501

MLS# 98977376

PENDING

$544,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Tomlinson Associates

1583 Lagoon Lane, Twin Falls, ID, 83301

MLS# 98979226

ACTIVE

$544,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Amherst Madison

11040 Springgold Dr, Boise, ID, 83709

MLS# 98981319

PENDING

$544,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Finding 43 Real Estate

Newly Listed

114 Pennsylvania St, Boise, ID, 83706

MLS# 98980163

ACTIVE

$544,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty Boise

Virtual Tour

9354 Inspirado St, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98978638

PENDING

$543,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Virtual Tour

6891 Chelsie Lynn Ave, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98973647

ACTIVE

$541,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Newly Listed

5679 Jumplist Ave, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98979985

PENDING

$541,254

4 Beds

Listing Office: Hubble Homes, LLC

Virtual Tour

5415 Bittercreek Ave, Meridian, ID, 83642

MLS# 98975519

ACTIVE

$540,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Newly Listed

5695 Jumplist Ave, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98981418

PENDING

$540,629

4 Beds

Listing Office: Hubble Homes, LLC

Newly Listed

3559 Fitz Roy St. UNIT Umpqua, Kuna, ID, 83634

MLS# 98980787

PENDING

$540,145

4 Beds

Listing Office: New Home Star Idaho

Newly Listed

2733 Sunray Loop, Twin Falls, ID, 83301

MLS# 98983069

ACTIVE

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Westerra Real Estate Group

Virtual Tour

Newly Listed

1301 A Street, Rupert, ID, 83350

MLS# 98981309

ACTIVE

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Westerra Real Estate Group

5657 W Song Sparrow St, Boise, ID, 83714

MLS# 98976154

ACTIVE

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Homes of Idaho

Virtual Tour

Newly Listed

1409 2000 E, Gooding, ID, 83330

MLS# 98982161

PENDING

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Riverside Realty

Newly Listed

600 Donna Drive, Nampa, ID, 83686-8860

MLS# 98983290

ACTIVE

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Tomlinson

Newly Listed

11240 West Blake Dr, Star, ID, 83669

MLS# 98983331

ACTIVE

$540,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Silvercreek Realty Group

Virtual Tour

Newly Listed

1066 Woods Bog Ave, Middleton, ID, 83644

MLS# 98979889

PENDING

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Virtual Tour

170 Willow Dale Dr., Kuna, ID, 83634

MLS# 98981188

ACTIVE

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: Hubble Homes, LLC

Virtual Tour

17381 Aspen Springs Way, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98970344

ACTIVE

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Virtual Tour

7795 Meriwether Dr, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98974097

ACTIVE

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: Hubble Homes, LLC

Virtual Tour

5426 Desert Cactus Ave, Meridian, ID, 83642

MLS# 98975518

PENDING

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Virtual Tour

11767 Snow Flower Dr, Star, ID, 83669

MLS# 98974767

PENDING

$539,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Virtual Tour

4680 Maplestone Ave, Meridian, ID, 83646-4928

MLS# 98970989

PENDING

$539,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Tomlinson

Virtual Tour

8943 Inspirado St, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98975207

PENDING

$539,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Newly Listed

8975 Tamworth Dr, Star, ID, 83669

MLS# 98978327

PENDING

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Toll Brothers Real Estate, Inc

1211 Mahogany St, Parma, ID, 83660

MLS# 98979530

ACTIVE

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Silvercreek Realty Group

Virtual Tour

243 Mountain View Dr., Albion, ID, 83311

MLS# 98979787

ACTIVE

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Turn Key Realty

Newly Listed

880 Redman, Chubbuck, ID, 83202

MLS# 98981752

ACTIVE

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Idaho Rocky Mountain Real Estate

3684 Stanwich Dr, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98970768

PENDING

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty Boise

Newly Listed

4010 N Patricia Lane, Boise, ID, 83704

MLS# 98983636

ACTIVE

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Kelly Right Real Estate-Idaho (branch)

118 Pennsylvania St, Boise, ID, 83706

MLS# 98968096

ACTIVE

$539,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty Boise

7242 Rygate Dr, Boise, ID, 83714

MLS# 98956594

PENDING

$538,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: New Home Star Idaho

Virtual Tour

7049 Daisy Teal Ave, Meridian, ID, 83646

MLS# 98974326

PENDING

$538,900

4 Beds

Listing Office: Lennar Sales Corp

Newly Listed

5587 Garby St. UNIT Lot 15 Block 8, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98973451

PENDING

$538,014

4 Beds

Listing Office: New Home Star Idaho

Virtual Tour

2397 Silver Wolf Ave, Star, ID, 83669

MLS# 98965840

ACTIVE

$536,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

Virtual Tour

8167 Cool River Lp, Nampa, ID, 83687

MLS# 98981582

ACTIVE

$535,990

4 Beds

Listing Office: CBH Sales & Marketing Inc

1440 Cerulean St, Kuna, ID, 83634

MLS# 98977815

ACTIVE

$535,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: RE/MAX Capital City

109 16th Ave W, Jerome, ID, 83338

MLS# 98979067

PENDING

$535,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Super Realty of Idaho

331 Reservoir Dr, Lewiston, ID, 83501

MLS# 98971424

ACTIVE

$535,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Century 21 Price Right

1407 S Roosevelt, Boise, ID, 83705

MLS# 98966310

ACTIVE

$535,000

4 Beds

Listing Office: Homes of Idaho

No similar listings found

Unfortunately, we don't have any similar listings at the moment. Please remove or change some of the selected filters.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IMLS does not assume any liability for missing or inaccurate data. Information provided by IMLS is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All listings provided by IMLS are marked with the official IMLS IDX logo. Updated: 27th April, 2026 3:37 PM (UTC)